Odio dignissimos blanditiis qui deleni atque corrupti.


The Point Newsletter

Sed ut perspiciatis unde omnis iste natus error.

Follow Point

Begin typing your search above and press return to search. Press Esc to cancel.
  • No products in the cart.
  /  Politics   /  Don’t Expect Labour to Mop Up U.K. Brexit Mess
John McDonnell and Jeremy Corbyn

Don’t Expect Labour to Mop Up U.K. Brexit Mess

With Prime Minister Theresa May’s Conservative Party tearing itself to pieces over Brexit, anyone might wonder whether the opposition Labour Party would do a better job directing the country’s divorce from the European Union. The prospect of new elections in the autumn or spring next year if May’s government implodes makes the question far from academic.

A recent poll from the Observer put the Labour Party four points ahead of the Tories, its biggest lead since the June 2017 general election, when Labour, led by Jeremy Corbyn, did unexpectedly well as supporters of closer ties with Europe defected from the Conservatives.

Meanwhile, May is bleeding support from all sides of the hugely divisive Brexit debate. In a scathing resignation speech in Parliament on Tuesday, ex-Foreign Secretary and chief Brexiter Boris Johnson attacked the “miserable permanent limbo” of her Brexit plan, saying it was tantamount to “volunteering for economic vassalage.” That was hours after she was criticized by strong Remain-supporting MPs, who voted against her in a key Brexit vote on Tuesday.

The Conservative infighting should create an open goal for the Labour Party. So far it hasn’t, and for several good reasons.

One is Labour’s own schizophrenia. If Conservatives are irreparably divided over Brexit, any unity Labour has shown is largely a veneer. In fact, May scraped by on two votes this week only with the help of a handful of Labour MPs — who defied their own party’s marching orders. In May, 83 Labour peers ignored their party’s line to back a vote in the House of Lords that effectively called for the U.K. to remain in the EU’s single market.

The official Labour position during the 2016 Brexit referendum was to remain in the EU, but Corbyn himself is a lifelong euroskeptic who sees the EU as a killer of his socialist dreams. And euroskepticism itself has a long Labour pedigree. In the 1975 referendum on membership in the European Economic Community, precursor to the EU, the balance among Labour members was 65 percent to 35 percent for leaving. Former Labour leader Michael Foot’s speech at the time of that referendum makes Boris Johnson’s Brexit credentials look almost weak:

And I say to our country — our great country — don’t be afraid! Don’t be afraid of those who tell us that we cannot run our affairs, that we have not the ingenuity to mobilize our resources and overcome our economic problems. Of course we have. We can do that and save the freedom of our country at the same time.

Corbyn has carefully built his Brexit strategy around the idea that he’s respecting the will of the people. He is acutely aware of the fact that Leave carried the day in over 60 percent of districts that elected a Labour MP, according to estimates by Christopher Hanretty, a politics professor at Royal Holloway University of London. That’s mainly because the anti-Brexit Labour voters were concentrated in London and other urban centers.

Corbyn also understands that anti-immigration sentiment was a major motivating factor for the Brexit vote. So while Labour supports remaining in the customs union, staying out of the single market means that Corbyn can promise tighter immigration restrictions; it also jibes with his plans for nationalizing various industries, which would probably be blocked under EU rules limiting government aid.